Utila vs. Roatán: Which Bay Island in Honduras Should You Visit?

Flights

Search for your next flight

Hotels

Fast and simple hotels with Booking

Activities

Book your next excursion with Viator

Insurance

Save on nomad travel insurance

How to pick the correct island for you?

I had the luxury of visiting both Utila and Roatán on my recent trip through Central America, and I spent considerable amounts of time exploring both islands.

If you have the time, I absolutely recommend visiting both. However, I do understand that most people either don’t have the time or the budget to go everywhere. I was very surprised to see how different these to islands truly were, so I’ll do my best to describe the differences below. I‘ll go into the vibe, the beaches, activities, food, accommodation and how to actually get there.

The Vibe - Laid-Back Utila vs. Polished Roatán

Utila is the definition of a no-shoes, no-problem kind of place. It’s tiny, walkable, and filled with backpackers, digital nomads, and dive instructors who came for a week and never left. You won’t find big resorts or chains here, just colorful wooden guesthouses, scooter traffic, and plenty of hammocks.

Roatán, on the other hand, feels more grown-up. It’s still got that island charm, but it’s more polished, especially in areas like West Bay. You’ll find beach clubs, nice restaurants, well-maintained roads, and luxury resorts with private beaches and swim-up bars. It’s more comfortable, but less intimate than Utila. You will find backpackers here too, just mostly in West End.

Beaches - Utila’s Hidden Spots vs. Roatán’s Showstoppers

Let’s be honest: Roatán wins in the beach department.

Roatán’s West Bay Beach is the kind of place you see on travel brochures. Long stretches of white sand, calm turquoise water, and palm trees for days. It’s perfect for snorkeling straight from shore and swimming with no waves. One negative aspect you need to take into account is that the beach gets pretty crowded on days there are cruise ships in port. Another lovely beach on Roatán is the Half Moon Bay beach located in West Bay. This might be my favorite!

Utila’s beaches are more rugged and hidden. Chepes Beach is the main one in town, simple and relaxed with some trees for shade. If you want something dreamier, you’ll need to take a boat to Water Caye, a postcard-perfect island off the coast that honestly felt like something out of a movie. You also have Neptunes, which is on the the main island of Utila, but still only reachable by boat.

You might also like to read...

How to Get to Neptune’s on Utila, Honduras - The Ultimate Beach Paradise

Diving & Snorkeling

Both islands are part of the Mesoamerican Barrier Reef, so you’re guaranteed amazing underwater life in either place. But how you dive is very different.

Utila is one of the cheapest places in the world to get scuba certified. Dive shops are everywhere and most come with built-in hostels or social atmospheres. It’s very much a “dive all day, hang at the beach bar all night” kind of island. Don’t get me wrong though, there is still lots of other things to do here.

Roatán has more upscale dive shops with higher prices, but also better boats and more comfortable facilities. You’ll also find amazing snorkeling right off the beach in West Bay and Half Moon Bay. I did lots of snorkeling here and had such an amazing time, especiallly finding so many starfish!

You might also like to read...

11 Fun Things to Do in Roatán, Honduras

You might also like to read...

14 Amazing Things to Do in Utila Other Than Diving

Food & Restaurants

Utila has cute local spots, beach bars, and cozy cafes, but the food scene is definitely smaller. Some of my favorites were Captain Willis for seafood and Josie’s Bakery for cinnamon buns and breakfast.

Roatán, especially in West End and West Bay, has a much bigger food scene. We loved Bariloche for BBQ or C Level Pizza for one of the best pizzas in Central America. There’s a broader variety too, Mexican, sushi, Italian, and vegan spots like Seawiches.

You might also like to read...

The Best Places to Eat in West End, Roatán - Best Restaurants For Every Budget

You might also like to read...

Best Places to Eat on Utila - Where I Actually Ate & Loved

Accommodation & Cost

Utila is the budget traveler’s dream. You can find private rooms for under $30 a night, and many dive shops offer free accommodation with dive courses. It’s easy to stay for cheap and still enjoy the island.

Roatán ranges from affordable guesthouses to full-on luxury resorts. If you want beachfront luxury with pools, private piers, and air con, Roatán’s your place. But you’ll definitely pay more for it. Expect mid-range rooms to start around $70–100+ per night.

You might also like to read...

Where to Stay in Roatán, Honduras: Area Guide & Top Hotels for Every Budget

Getting There

Utila is harder to get to. You’ll need to take a ferry from La Ceiba or from Roatán (the ferry takes about 1 hour), or fly from La Ceiba on a tiny plane.

Roatán has an international airport with direct flights from the US and Canada, making it a much easier option if you’re on a tighter schedule or want a smoother arrival.

However, I wouldn’t base my decision on this unless you only have a couple of days total to spend on either island.

So… Should You Go to Utila or Roatán?

Honestly, both are worth visiting and I truly had an amazing time on both islands! If you have time, the dream combo is doing both! Spend a few days diving and chilling in Utila, then hop over to Roatán for beach luxury and cocktails at sunset.

But if you need to choose:

Go to Utila if you:

• Are on a backpacker budget
• Want to get scuba certified
• Prefer a smaller, walkable island with a chill vibe
• Don’t mind rustic beaches

Go to Roatán if you:

• Want dreamy beaches and luxury stays
• Prefer convenience and easy transport
• Love good food and diverse restaurants
• Want better infrastructure and options for families or couples

I hope this guide helps you pick the right island for you!

If you have any questions about Utila, Roatán or Honduras in general, please don’t hesitate to reach out to me on social media. I would love to connect and help out!

-Ingrid

You might also like to read...

The Perfect 2-Week Belize Itinerary: Caye Caulker, San Ignacio & the Hummingbird Highway

You might also like to read...

The Ultimate 10-Day El Salvador Itinerary: Volcanoes, Colonial Towns & Mayan Ruins

You might also like to read...

2 week Itinerary Guatemala - From Hiking Volcanoes to Exploring Ancient Ruins